From Marx to Lenin: An evaluation of Marx's responsibility for Soviet authoritarianism

By David W. Lovell

This research is a contribution to the controversy, all started simply after the October Revolution, in regards to the courting among Marx's venture and Soviet society. It focuses, even though, merely at the political features of the problem: to what quantity was once early Soviet authoritarianism the required consequence of Marx's works? considering the fact that Lenin's perform and thought mostly decided and justified the early political personality of the Soviet country, we could ask no matter if Lenin used to be imposing Marx's undertaking or a venture of his personal layout. Lenin, stimulated by means of debates inside Social Democracy and by way of the adventure of the Russian innovative culture, used a one-sided interpretation of Marx's paintings to construct and shield a 'transition' which used to be essentially authoritarian. Marx was once no longer causally accountable for the theoretical origin of Soviet authoritarianism.

Show description

Quick preview of From Marx to Lenin: An evaluation of Marx's responsibility for Soviet authoritarianism PDF

Best Socialism books

New Road to Serfdom, The

In global warfare II, American infantrymen went out of the country to rescue England from the Nazi risk. Now, with the USA threatened from inside by means of the threat of social democracy, British flesh presser Daniel Hannan returns the prefer. the hot highway to Serfdom is a must-read rallying cry for Tea social gathering activists, fanatics of Mark Levin’s Tyranny and Liberty, and an individual who has obvious Hannan’s hard-hitting interviews with Hannity & Colmes, Neil Cavuto, and Glenn Beck.

Marx at the Margins: On Nationalism, Ethnicity, and Non-Western Societies

In Marx on the Margins, Kevin Anderson uncovers numerous large yet missed texts via Marx that forged what we notion we knew approximately his paintings in a startlingly assorted mild. examining a number of Marx’s writings, together with journalistic paintings written for the hot York Tribune, Anderson offers us with a Marx relatively at odds with traditional interpretations.

Cybernetic Revolutionaries: Technology and Politics in Allende's Chile (MIT Press)

In Cybernetic Revolutionaries, Eden Medina tells the background of 2 intersecting utopian visions, one political and one technological. the 1st used to be Chile's scan with peaceable socialist switch lower than Salvador Allende; the second one used to be the simultaneous try and construct a working laptop or computer procedure that may deal with Chile's economic climate.

The New Radicalism in America 1889-1963: The Intellectual as a Social Type

"Extraordinarily inventive . . . an immense and engrossing contribution to a posh and elusive topic. "―Newsweek round the flip of the century, the yankee liberal culture made a tremendous shift clear of politics. the hot radicals have been extra attracted to the reform of schooling, tradition, and sexual mores.

Additional info for From Marx to Lenin: An evaluation of Marx's responsibility for Soviet authoritarianism

Show sample text content

Within the theoretical feel they need to fail as a result of their it sounds as if divided dedication to the Soviet Union and to a liberal democratic transition to socialism. however, the talk over Eurocommunism raised concerns which Cambridge Books on-line © Cambridge college Press, 2012 Introduction are not less than as outdated because the Soviet republic: is Marx's undertaking necessarily authoritarian; and in which lie the motives of Soviet authoritarianism? particularly, it raised the problems of the level to which Lenin used to be guided via Marx's rules in top the October Revolution; the level to which the political physiognomy of the Soviet nation was once motivated through Marx's undertaking, Lenin's interpretation of it, Russia's social, financial, and cultural background, or non permanent tactical issues; and the level to which Stalin's Russia used to be an important improvement of Lenin's Russia, and even if in flip all this is without delay derived from Marx. The scope of this learn isn't really as formidable, yet Eurocommunism brings into concentration an important questions. If we ask even if the information of Marx, the information and political technique of Lenin, and the socio-political order of the early Soviet nation are to be conceived when it comes to a primary continuity, or a primary discontinuity, we needs to determine not just the connection among Marx and Lenin, however the courting among Lenin and the Soviet nation. used to be Lenin answerable for the political positive aspects of the Soviet republic until eventually at the very least the tip of 1918? i exploit that date as an end-point simply because, having undertaken the October coup, Lenin and his get together had by way of the tip of 1918 made the choices when it comes to liberal democracy and dictatorship which might mostly ensure the nature of the recent regime: the coup itself, the dissolution of the Constituent meeting, the Treaty of BrestLitovsk, and the selections on peasant land-tenure. 22 After this time additionally, not anything a lot remained of novel Leninist23 theorizing which needed to do with except the phenomenal state of affairs during which the Bolsheviks now learned they'd landed, how one can look after Bolshevik strength, and the way to beat the exigencies of the instant. it's maybe unfair to pass judgement on Lenin in his nation of perpetual hindrance, other than in as far as that country was once ready and because of him. So how a ways was once Lenin accountable for the authoritarian nature of the early Soviet country, its abandonment of consultant democracy, unfastened elections, a unfastened press, and civil rights? How a ways, that's, was once Lenin's coverage based upon, or the result of, his thought; how a ways used to be thought an insignificant explanation, the handmaiden of a coverage which had Bolshevik energy at its centre, yet over which Lenin had little regulate? used to be Lenin on top of things and, if Cambridge Books on-line © Cambridge college Press, 2012 From Marx to Lenin so, used to be it his theoretical issues which made up our minds his perform, or was once Lenin being managed by way of conditions and occasions which crushed him? One can't exclude or deny the consequences of situations which attended the beginning of the Soviet nation, nor the consequences of initiatives which any executive, without reference to specific long term social targets, needed to fulfil on the time.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.22 of 5 – based on 45 votes